Hermanos v. Saldaña

TEEHANKEE, J.:

The Court, in affirming the decision under review of the Court of Appeals, which holds that the respondent buyer of two small residential lots on installment contracts on a ten-year basis who has faithfully paid for eight continuous years on the principal alone already more than the value of one lot, besides the larger stipulated interests on both lots, is entitled to the conveyance of one fully paid lot of his choice, rules that the judgment is fair and just and in accordance with law and equity. The action originated as a complaint for delivery of two parcels of land in Sampaloc, Manila and for execution of the corresponding deed of conveyance after payment of the balance still due on their purchase price. Private respondent as plaintiff had entered into two written contracts with petitioner Legarda Hermanos as defendant subdivision owner, whereby the latter agreed to sell to him Lots Nos. 7 and 8 of block No. 5N of the subdivision with an area of 150 square meters each, for the sum of P1,500.00 per lot, payable over the span of ten years divided into 120 equal monthly installments of P19.83 with 10% interest per annum, to commence on May 26, 1948, date of execution of the contracts.

Subsequently, Legarda Hermanos partitioned the subdivision among the brothers and sisters, and the two lots were among those allotted to co-petitioner Jose Legarda who was then included as co-defendant in the action. It is undisputed that respondent faithfully paid for eight continuous years about 95 (of the stipulated 120) monthly installments totalling P3,582.06 up to the month of February, 1956, which as per petitioners' own statement of account, Exhibit "1", was applied to respondent's account (without distinguishing the two lots), as follows: To interests P1,889.78 To principal 1,682.28